This is a little experiment inspired by Psycon 2024 in Chicago, and the fellow psychos I met there (especially one in particular. You know who you are :). Meeting those psychos renewed my enthusiasm for this silly but still great show. I'm now doing a rewatch while listening to Tim and Maggie's podcast and doing a tier-list / episode review hybrid, and just diving in whole hog! Really hoping Psych 4 sees the light of day!
| Tiers | Episodes |
|---|---|
| S (2) | S8E01 - Lock, Stock, Some Smoking Barrels and Burton Guster's Goblet of Fire |
| S8E10 - The Break-Up | |
| A+ (5) | S8E02 - S.E.I.Z.E. the Day |
| S8E06 - 1967: A Psych Odyssey | |
| A (2) | S8E03 - Remake A.K.A. Cloud... |
Top tier S tier:
S2E01 - American Duos
S2E13 - Lights, Camera... Homicidio
S2E15 - Black and Tan: A Crime of Fashion
S5E02 - Last Night Gus
S7E03 - Lassie Jerky
S7E05 - 100 Clues
S7E08 - Right Turn or Left for Dead
S7E11 - Office Space
S8E01 - Lock, Stock, Some Smoking Barrels and Burton Guster's...| Tiers | Episodes |
|---|---|
| S (4) | S7E03 - Lassie Jerky |
| S7E05 - 100 Clues | |
| S7E08 - Right Turn or Left for Dead | |
| S7E11 - Office Space | |
| A+ (5) | S7E01 - Santabarbaratown 2 |
| S7E04 - No Country for Two Old Men | |
| S7E09 - Juliet Wears... |
| Tiers | Episodes |
|---|---|
| S (4) | S5E02 - Last Night Gus |
| S6E03 - This Episode Sucks | |
| S6E10 - Indiana Shawn and the Temple of the Kinda Crappy, Rusty Old Dagger | |
| S6E11 - Heeeeere's Lassie | |
| A+ (6) | S6E01 - Shawn Rescues Darth Vader |
| S6E... |
| Tiers | Episodes |
|---|---|
| S (6) | S5E06 - Viagra Falls |
| S5E10 - Extradition II: The Actual Extradition Part | |
| S5E12 - Dual Spires | |
| S5E13 - We'd Like to Thank the Academy | |
| S5E15 - Dead Bear Walking | |
| S5E16 - Yang 3 in 2D | |
| A+ (3) | ...
| Tiers | Episodes |
|---|---|
| S (3) | S4E01 - Extradition: British Columbia |
| S4E09 - Shawn Takes a Shot in the Dark | |
| S4E16 - Mr. Yin Presents... | |
| A+ (4) | S4E11 - Thrill Seekers and Hell-Raisers |
| S4E12 - A Very Juliet Episode | |
| S4E14 - Think... |
| Tiers | Episodes |
|---|---|
| S (2) | S3E08 - Gus Walks into a Bank |
| S3E16 - An Evening with Mr. Yang | |
| A+ (6) | S3E02 - Murder? … Anyone? … Anyone? … Bueller? |
| S3E04 - The Greatest Adventure in the History of Basic Cable | |
| S3E05 - Disco Didn't Die. I... |
| Tiers | Episodes |
|---|---|
| S (3) | S2E01 - American Duos |
| S2E13 - Lights, Camera... Homicidio | |
| S2E15 - Black and Tan: A Crime of Fashion | |
| A+ (4) | S2E02 - 65 Million Years Off |
| S2E03 - Psy vs. Psy | |
| S2E06 - Meat Is Murder, But Murder Is A... |
| Tiers | Episodes |
|---|---|
| S (3) | S1E01 – Pilot |
| S1E10 – From the Earth to the Starbucks | |
| S1E15 – Scary Sherry: Bianca’s Toast | |
| A+ (3) | S1E05 – 9 Lives |
| S1E06 – Weekend Warriors | |
| S1E08 – Shawn vs. the Red Phantom | |
| A (6... |